Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This doesn't affect our recommendations or editorial integrity. Learn more

Soda Makers

Expert Picks for January 2026

Best Soda Makers

DIY sparkling water at pennies per liter. We compared soda makers from SodaStream to Aarke—comparing carbonation control, CO2 economics, and whether DrinkMate's carbonate-anything promise delivers.

Last updated: January 28, 2026
Share:
Best Overall Our top recommendation
Best Overall
Art Sparkling Water Maker

SodaStream

Art Sparkling Water Maker

4.6 (8,765 reviews)

The Art is SodaStream's design statement. Manual lever gives carbonation control. The SodaStream for kitchen aesthetes.

Bottle

1L included

CO2

60L cylinder

Power

Manual lever

Design

Retro

Pros

  • Retro-modern design
  • Manual lever = no batteries
  • Quick-connect CO2

Cons

  • Premium pricing
  • Proprietary bottles
  • CO2 exchanges add up

Head-to-Head Comparison

ProductRatingPrice Action
Art Sparkling Water Maker
Art Sparkling Water Maker Best
SodaStream
4.6
$150 View
Terra Sparkling Water Maker
Terra Sparkling Water Maker Value
SodaStream
4.5
$90 View
Carbonator 3
Carbonator 3
Aarke
4.7
$229 View
OmniFizz Sparkling Water Maker
OmniFizz Sparkling Water Maker
DrinkMate
4.4
$110 View
One Touch Sparkling Water Maker
One Touch Sparkling Water Maker
SodaStream
4.3
$130 View

* Prices may vary. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

All Recommended Products

Best Overall
Art Sparkling Water Maker

SodaStream

Art Sparkling Water Maker

4.6 (8,765 reviews)

The Art is SodaStream's design statement. Manual lever gives carbonation control. The SodaStream for kitchen aesthetes.

Bottle

1L included

CO2

60L cylinder

Power

Manual lever

Design

Retro

Pros

  • Retro-modern design
  • Manual lever = no batteries
  • Quick-connect CO2

Cons

  • Premium pricing
  • Proprietary bottles
  • CO2 exchanges add up
Best Value
Terra Sparkling Water Maker

SodaStream

Terra Sparkling Water Maker

4.5 (23,456 reviews)

The Terra is SodaStream simplified—same carbonation, cleaner design, $60 less than the Art.

Bottle

1L included

CO2

60L cylinder

Power

Manual

Bottle System

Quick-connect

Pros

  • Best value SodaStream
  • Quick-connect system
  • Slim design

Cons

  • Basic design
  • Same proprietary bottles
  • CO2 requires exchanges
Premium Pick
Carbonator 3

Aarke

Carbonator 3

4.7 (5,678 reviews)

Aarke is the Porsche of soda makers—same function, premium packaging. Worth it if aesthetics matter. Ridiculous if they don't.

Material

Stainless steel

CO2

SodaStream compatible

Bottle

PET included

Design

Swedish

Pros

  • Stunning Swedish design
  • Stainless steel construction
  • Premium materials

Cons

  • Very expensive
  • Same function as cheaper
  • Design tax
OmniFizz Sparkling Water Maker

DrinkMate

OmniFizz Sparkling Water Maker

4.4 (4,567 reviews)

DrinkMate's secret: it carbonates anything. Juice, wine, cocktails—all fair game. For creative carbonation, this is the choice.

Bottles

1L + 0.5L included

CO2

60L cylinder

Unique

Any beverage capable

Fizz Button

Pressure release

Pros

  • Carbonates ANY drink
  • Juice, wine, cocktails
  • SodaStream CO2 compatible

Cons

  • Bulkier design
  • More complex
  • Fizz infuser needs cleaning
Budget Pick
One Touch Sparkling Water Maker

SodaStream

One Touch Sparkling Water Maker

4.3 (3,456 reviews)

The One Touch removes manual pumping—press a button, get consistent bubbles. Nice for those who hate manual devices.

Power

Electric

Levels

3 preset

Bottle

1L included

CO2

60L cylinder

Pros

  • Electric = consistent carbonation
  • Three preset levels
  • LED indicators

Cons

  • Requires power outlet
  • Electronics can fail
  • Cord management

Buying Guide: How to Choose Soda Makers


Soda Makers: DIY Sparkling Water

Why Make Your Own?
Economics: ~$0.25/liter vs $1-2/bottle
Environment: No plastic bottles
Freshness: Carbonate when you drink
Control: Light fizz to face-melting bubbles

### SodaStream vs Alternatives
SodaStream: Largest market share, easy CO2 exchanges, water only
Aarke: Design premium, uses SodaStream CO2
DrinkMate: Carbonates any liquid, more complex

### The CO2 Question
SodaStream cylinders: ~60L per fill, $15 exchange. Third-party adapters let you use larger tanks (cheaper, voids warranty).

Frequently Asked Questions About Soda Makers

Is making soda water cheaper?

Yes. ~$0.25/liter vs $1-2 store-bought. Break even within months.

How long do bottles last?

PET bottles expire 3-4 years. Replace when expired—safety issue.

Can I use third-party CO2 tanks?

With adapters, yes. Voids warranty, requires careful handling.

Why did my bottle explode?

Over-carbonation or expired bottle. Never exceed recommended pumps. Don't carbonate warm liquid.

Was this guide helpful?

Why Trust Our Recommendations?

We analyze thousands of real customer reviews, compare product specifications, and curate recommendations so you can make an informed decision without the research hassle.

Curated Recommendations
Real Customer Reviews
Specs Compared
No Paid Placements