Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This doesn't affect our recommendations or editorial integrity. Learn more

Expert Picks for January 2026

Best Bar Shampoo

Shampoo bottles are unnecessary. We compared bar shampoos for lather, hair health, and not leaving your head feeling waxy—finding what works for different hair types.

Last updated: January 28, 2026
Share:
Best Overall Our top recommendation
Best Overall
Mintasy Shampoo Bar

Ethique

Mintasy Shampoo Bar

4.5 (34,567 reviews)

The bar that converted skeptics. Ethique's formula lathers like liquid shampoo and rinses clean without residue. The mint scent wakes you up, the results keep you converted. One bar = three bottles.

Size

3.88 oz

Equivalent

3 liquid bottles

Packaging

Compostable box

Sulfate

Free

Pros

  • Equivalent to 3 bottles
  • Zero plastic packaging
  • Salon quality ingredients

Cons

  • Adjustment period
  • Can get mushy
  • Not for all hair types

Head-to-Head Comparison

ProductRatingPrice Action
Mintasy Shampoo Bar
Mintasy Shampoo Bar Best
Ethique
4.5
$16 View
Moisturize Shampoo Bar
Moisturize Shampoo Bar
HiBAR
4.6
$14 View
Jumping Juniper Shampoo Bar
Jumping Juniper Shampoo Bar Value
Lush
4.4
$13 View
Old Fashioned Shampoo Bar
Old Fashioned Shampoo Bar
J.R. Liggett's
4.3
$8 View
Rice Water Shampoo Bar
Rice Water Shampoo Bar
Kitsch
4.5
$12 View

* Prices may vary. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

All Recommended Products

Best Overall
Mintasy Shampoo Bar

Ethique

Mintasy Shampoo Bar

4.5 (34,567 reviews)

The bar that converted skeptics. Ethique's formula lathers like liquid shampoo and rinses clean without residue. The mint scent wakes you up, the results keep you converted. One bar = three bottles.

Size

3.88 oz

Equivalent

3 liquid bottles

Packaging

Compostable box

Sulfate

Free

Pros

  • Equivalent to 3 bottles
  • Zero plastic packaging
  • Salon quality ingredients

Cons

  • Adjustment period
  • Can get mushy
  • Not for all hair types
Premium Pick
Moisturize Shampoo Bar

HiBAR

Moisturize Shampoo Bar

4.6 (12,345 reviews)

The salon-quality option. HiBAR was developed by actual salon chemists who got frustrated with eco-products that didn't perform. The result: bars that work immediately, no "transition period" needed.

Size

2.9 oz

Equivalent

80+ washes

Formula

Salon-grade

Options

Moisturize, Volumize, Maintain

Pros

  • Salon-developed formulas
  • Different types for different hair
  • No transition period

Cons

  • Smaller bar
  • Fewer lathers per bar
  • Premium price per wash
Best Value
Jumping Juniper Shampoo Bar

Lush

Jumping Juniper Shampoo Bar

4.4 (45,678 reviews)

The accessible entry point. Lush has sold shampoo bars for decades, and they're available everywhere. Strong scents, solid performance, good for those who want to smell like a forest or bakery.

Size

1.9 oz

Equivalent

80 washes

Feature

Fresh handmade

Scent

Juniper berry

Pros

  • Well-known brand
  • Unique scents
  • Good for oily hair

Cons

  • Contains sulfates
  • Strong fragrances
  • Crumbly over time
Budget Pick
Old Fashioned Shampoo Bar

J.R. Liggett's

Old Fashioned Shampoo Bar

4.3 (23,456 reviews)

Old-school shampoo bar—literally soap for your hair. Works great with an apple cider vinegar rinse to balance pH and close cuticles. Budget-friendly and simple, but requires technique.

Size

3.5 oz

Ingredient

Olive oil, coconut oil

Type

Traditional soap

Scents

Multiple options

Pros

  • True soap bar
  • All-natural ingredients
  • Budget friendly

Cons

  • Requires ACV rinse
  • Not for hard water
  • Adjustment period
Rice Water Shampoo Bar

Kitsch

Rice Water Shampoo Bar

4.5 (28,934 reviews)

Riding the rice water trend in bar form. Fermented rice water has centuries of hair-strengthening history. This bar delivers it conveniently, with a gentle formula good for fine or damaged hair.

Size

3.2 oz

Key Ingredient

Fermented rice water

Formula

Sulfate-free

Target

Hair growth

Pros

  • Rice water trend
  • Good for hair growth
  • Pretty packaging

Cons

  • Softer bar
  • Can get gummy
  • More for fine hair

Buying Guide: How to Choose Bar Shampoo


How to Choose Bar Shampoo

Shampoo bottles are one of the worst bathroom plastic offenders—Americans throw away 550 million per year. Bar shampoo eliminates the bottle entirely while often lasting longer than liquid equivalents.

The Transition Period

Many people experience an adjustment phase when switching to bar shampoo—hair feels waxy, greasy, or different. This lasts 1-3 weeks as your scalp adjusts and old product residue washes out. Some bars skip this entirely (HiBAR, Ethique) while others require it (traditional soap bars).

### Bar Types

Solid Shampoo Bars
Shampoo ingredients pressed into bar form. pH balanced, no vinegar rinse needed. Closest to liquid shampoo experience. Ethique, HiBAR, most modern brands.

Shampoo Soap Bars
Actual soap (saponified oils). Works differently—higher pH, may need acid rinse. More "natural" but more technique required. J.R. Liggett's style.

### Matching to Hair Type

Oily Hair: Look for clarifying formulas, mint, tea tree
Dry Hair: Moisturizing formulas, coconut oil, shea butter
Color-Treated: Gentle, sulfate-free, color-safe labeled
Fine Hair: Volumizing formulas, avoid heavy moisturizers
Curly Hair: Hydrating, gentle, avoid sulfates

### Storage Matters

Bars need to dry between uses or they become mush. Use a soap dish that drains, a soap saver bag, or cut bars in half. Never store in a pool of shower water. Proper storage dramatically extends bar life.

### Environmental Math

One shampoo bar typically equals 2-3 liquid bottles. Over a year, a family of four saves 12-20 plastic bottles. Bars ship lighter (no water weight), reducing carbon footprint. The switch makes measurable difference.

Frequently Asked Questions About Bar Shampoo

Why does my hair feel weird after switching to bar shampoo?

Your scalp is adjusting to different ingredients (usually fewer detergents) and old silicone buildup is washing out. This transition takes 1-3 weeks. Use an apple cider vinegar rinse to help. Modern bars like Ethique and HiBAR minimize this phase with pH-balanced formulas.

Do I need a special conditioner with bar shampoo?

Not necessarily, but conditioner bars exist too. Bar shampoo can be more stripping than liquid, so dry or damaged hair may need conditioner. Many brands make matching bar conditioners. Or use a small amount of your regular liquid conditioner.

How do I use bar shampoo correctly?

Wet hair thoroughly. Rub bar between hands to create lather, or rub directly on scalp. Massage lather through hair focusing on scalp. Rinse completely. The key is enough water—bar shampoo needs more water than liquid to activate.

Why did my bar get mushy and fall apart?

Water exposure between uses. Bars need to dry completely to stay solid. Get a draining soap dish, keep away from direct shower spray, or store outside the shower. Some people cut bars in half so one piece stays dry while using the other.

Was this guide helpful?

Why Trust Our Recommendations?

We analyze thousands of real customer reviews, compare product specifications, and curate recommendations so you can make an informed decision without the research hassle.

Curated Recommendations
Real Customer Reviews
Specs Compared
No Paid Placements